Aaron Judge secured the 2024 AL MVP award, while Shohei Ohtani took home the NL MVP title. Both players excelled throughout the season and reached the World Series, sparking debate over who is truly the better player.
Ex-Twins slugger Trevor Plouffe expressed a strong belief that Judge would surpass Ohtani for a league-wide MVP accolade,
citing Judge’s field play and impressive offensive record as key factors. Although he acknowledges Derek Jeter’s cultural impact, Plouffe asserts that Judge is the superior baseball player.
By the Numbers
Aaron Judge hit 58 home runs and drove in 144 RBIs during the 2024 season.
He has been named AL MVP twice in the last three seasons.
Yes, But
While Plouffe champions Judge’s qualifications for MVP, some argue that Ohtani’s two-way capabilities make him equally deserving. The ongoing discourse highlights the subjective nature of MVP selection in the league.
State of Play
Both Judge and Ohtani are major players heading into the offseason after their successful seasons.
The Yankees are engaged in negotiations to retain star Juan Soto amidst interest from multiple teams.
What’s Next
The discussion around the MVP race will likely continue, especially as the offseason unfolds and teams make roster decisions. With Judge’s performance under scrutiny, his aspirations for a World Series title remain a focal point.
Bottom Line
While both Aaron Judge and Shohei Ohtani have made significant impacts in their leagues, Judge’s combination of offensive excellence and defensive contributions positions him as a leading candidate for a league-wide MVP. This debate reflects the complexities and passions involved in defining greatness in baseball.
Leave a Reply